Let me guess, you thought doom 3 was good?

No, it sucked too. :)

Doom3 sucked because it was too dark and the gameplay was slow. It should have been bright and fast paced action just like the original Doom.

Personally I think HL2 was just "ok", nothing to write home about, Painkiller is probably the best game to come out in a long time, too bad multiplayer was such a tremendous hassle, call of duty-UO is second best. Doom3 kinda sux'd but I want to see quake4 and Envy when they come out, they should blow away anything we have ever seen to date.