Onboard sound or PCI sound card

These links are no good. These are not public access files. Browser returns no permission error. .

This topic was started by ,


data/avatar/default/avatar03.webp

399 Posts
Location -
Joined 2003-03-22
I have a Sound Blaster live 5.1 (pci sound card), i also have a onboard AC97 6.1 sound chip which come from my MSI KT4V (Via Apollo KT400).

I am running Windows XP with S2k (Athlon cooling program). Without the sound card i manage to futher reduce the temperature 5C (total 9C).

Ok my question is that should i keep using the PCI sound card? Cause the onboard sound is quite good compare with my sb live 5.1 (infact no different can be heard). I am planing to overclock further more because i get lower temperature without the card.

Some words of wisdom please?

Thanks in advance.

Participate on our website and join the conversation

You have already an account on our website? Use the link below to login.
Login
Create a new user account. Registration is free and takes only a few seconds.
Register
This topic is archived. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast.

Responses to this topic


assets/images/contentteller/avatar_disabled.webp

0 Posts
Location -
Joined -
just look how the cooling apps do work ... it using BUS DISCONNET !! search google for that ... now anytime the soundcard ask for status the cooling state is aborted for short time ...

anyway ... to answere the question my way ...
the +on idle cooling is not worth NOT using a good soundcard like an Audigy2
it must be a difference of 50K then to let me think about ...

data/avatar/default/avatar03.webp

399 Posts
Location -
Joined 2003-03-22
OP
The problem is that i don't have an aydigy 2 :cry: which is way better then the onboard sound system. I only have a sb live 5.1 which might not be very powerful then the onboard sound chip or may be worse or equivalent.

assets/images/contentteller/avatar_disabled.webp

0 Posts
Location -
Joined -
an normal AC97 it not worth ...
If ya got to choose between SBLive! and nForce Soundstorm ... OK but just a normal AC97 ...
just use the ABLive with the PAX drivers modded to audigy and you will be fine ...

data/avatar/default/avatar03.webp

399 Posts
Location -
Joined 2003-03-22
OP
Does the Moded have any advantages? Anyway, i decided to used the PCI sound card agian, cause my system still runs in acceptable temperature after OC with the card on.

assets/images/contentteller/avatar_disabled.webp

0 Posts
Location -
Joined -
yes it does ... since I do not use any of the special features ... this part was equal to me ... but the sound is better for sure ...
you know its VERY hard to describe ... you jut got to try yourselfe ... it just sounds better

data/avatar/default/avatar03.webp

2 Posts
Location -
Joined 2004-05-18
You should definitely go the PCI card route
- generally they use less cpu time than an onboard soundchip, and will offer more features e.g. hardware d3d, positional sound, EAX etc - all good for gaming

SBLive 5.1 is still way better than AC97